Pageant Score Sheet: A Free Printable, and How to Use It

Directors

Your pageant is set, your judges are booked, and you still need something for them to write on. A good score sheet does three jobs: it makes each judge score the same way, it makes the totals easy to check, and it leaves a record if a family asks how a decision was made.

Download the free pageant score sheet (PDF)

It is two pages. Print as many of each as you need.

What is on the pageant score sheet?

The first page is the judge's score sheet, one per judge for each area of competition. The second is the tally sheet, which whoever adds up the scores fills in.

Page Who fills it in What it holds
Judge's score sheet Each judge, once per area Contestant number and name, a score from 1 to 10, notes, the judge's signature
Tally sheet Your tabulator Each area's name and weight, every contestant's average per area, the total, the place, your tiebreaker

The notes column matters more than it looks. When a parent asks what their child could work on, a judge's note is the answer you give them.

How should judges score?

Ask every judge to follow the same four rules. They are printed at the bottom of the sheet:

  • A whole number from 1 to 10. Miss America's 2016 judges manual used this scale, and it is easy to total by hand.
  • Against the standard, not each other. Each contestant is measured against what a great interview or a great walk looks like, not against the one before.
  • Ties are allowed. Two contestants can earn the same score in one area. Their other areas usually separate them in the total.
  • Initial any change. Cross the old score out, write the new one beside it and initial it. A sheet with a clean change is a sheet nobody argues with.

Collect the sheets as each area ends, so the tallying keeps up with the show.

How much is each area of competition worth?

Each area gets a weight, and the weights add up to 100%. Two well known systems publish theirs:

Area Miss America, local pageants National American Miss
Interview 30% 30%
Talent 20%
Fitness 20%
Evening wear or formal wear 20% 30%
Onstage question 10%
Personal introduction 30%
Community service project 10%

Sources: Miss America (state and local scoring), National American Miss (FAQ), both checked 11/10/2026.

Both put interview at 30%, and that is a fair place to start. Set your own weights by what your title asks of the winner: a titleholder who will speak at schools and events needs interview to count heavily. Our guide to pageant categories walks through what each area judges.

Put the weights in your rules before entries open, so families know what they are preparing for.

How do you add up the scores?

For each contestant and each area:

  1. Average the judges' scores for that area.
  2. Multiply the average by the area's weight.
  3. Add the results. That is the total, out of 10.

Using the Miss America local weights, a contestant who averages 8 in interview, 7 in talent, 9 in fitness, 8 in evening wear and 6 on the onstage question scores:

Area Average Weight Points
Interview 8 30% 2.4
Talent 7 20% 1.4
Fitness 9 20% 1.8
Evening wear 8 20% 1.6
Onstage question 6 10% 0.6
Total 7.8

Have a second person check every total before results go to the emcee. The tally sheet has a line for their name.

How do you break a tie?

Decide before the pageant, tell the judges, and write it on the tally sheet. The most common rule is the higher score in the area with the most weight, usually interview. If that is also tied, go to the next heaviest area.

What you want to avoid is deciding at 10 PM with two families watching.

When paper gets slow

Paper works, and for a small pageant it works well. It gets slow when you have many divisions, five judges and a crowning that is waiting on a calculator.

We are building judging into Pageant Post, so scores add themselves up as judges enter them. Until then, print this one. If you also run People's Choice, see how $1 = 1 vote works.

Frequently asked questions

What scale do pageant judges score on?

Many pageants use 1 to 10 in whole numbers for each area of competition. Miss America's 2016 judges manual set it that way, and it is easy to total by hand. Some systems use 1 to 100 or allow decimals; whatever you choose, use the same scale for every area.

What are pageant judging criteria?

Each area of competition, such as interview or evening wear, has its own criteria and its own weight. National American Miss weights personal introduction, formal wear modeling and interview at 30% each, plus a 10% community service project. Miss America's local pageants weight private interview 30%, and fitness, talent and evening wear 20% each, plus a 10% onstage question.

How do you total pageant scores?

Average the judges' scores in each area, multiply each average by that area's weight, and add the results. With weights of 30, 20, 20, 20 and 10%, averages of 8, 7, 9, 8 and 6 give a total of 7.8 out of 10.

How do you break a tie in a pageant?

Decide the rule before anyone is scored and tell the judges. A common choice is the higher score in the most heavily weighted area, usually interview. Writing it on the tally sheet keeps the decision from being made under pressure on the night.

Run your next pageant with Pageant Post

Registration, judging, tabulation, check-in, payouts, and People's Choice voting, all in one place. Free until your voters vote.

Host a pageant, free